On-line
tool: Step 4 - The catch
The medium-sized exemption is much less helpful
than the small-sized one. There is a further limitation which
seems likely in practice to deny medium-sized taxpayers much of the
certainty they might have hoped to gain from qualifying for the
exemption.
“To further protect revenues”, the Inland Revenue will have the power
to withdraw the exemption for medium-sized taxpayers whom they
notify.
The Inland Revenue will exercise this power
retrospectively, after the taxpayer has submitted its tax return.
A notice will be issued, requiring the taxpayer to recompute their tax
return, increasing their taxable profits where necessary to reflect
arm's length transfer prices. The notice may apply to
all of the taxpayer’s transactions with related parties, or could
relate to specified transactions only.
Apparently this power will only be used
“where a significant amount of tax is at stake”. The legislation
does not define what is a significant amount of
tax, and nor does any Inland Revenue guidance give any clear lines in
the sand, so we will be at the
mercy of individual Inspectors of Tax.
Most worryingly, the taxpayer will have only 90 days to submit a
revised tax return. Any understatement of tax that remains at
that point will be exposed to potential penalties. 90 days is not
long to carry out a transfer pricing analysis from scratch. At
best, the taxpayer will have to drop other activities and throw
resources at the analysis to complete it in 90 days. At worst, it
will be nigh-on impossible.
So, medium-sized companies still face a realistic risk of transfer
pricing adjustment and the possibility of having 90 days to do enough
work to avoid penalties. In practice, many UK taxpayers with
significant
transactions with related parties (in the UK or overseas) may decide
they have no choice but to carry out at least some high level analysis
of their transfer pricing position, in order to determine their
potential exposures.
The 'small print'
The
comments on this page and elsewhere on this website are of a
general nature. It is not practicable in a general review such as
this
to consider every convolution of the UK transfer pricing rules or of
any other tax law that may be relevant. Moreover, these pages
naturally do not take into account the specific facts relating to any
particular taxpayer. Therefore, although the guidance in this
website
should give a good indication of the likely position under the transfer
pricing rules, taxpayers should obtain professional advice to verify
the position, or carry out their own analysis.
Neither
TPS nor its affiliates
and employees
make any representation regarding the
completeness or accuracy thereof and they accept no responsibility for
any loss or damage incurred as a result of any user acting or
refraining from acting upon anything contained on these pages or upon
its omission therefrom.
|